In Harris's lair, Ian asks Eve to remember their love. Although she's unsure, Ian professes his love and says they'll make it. Rafe asks the other angels who they think will be the 5th chair. They accuse him of wanting it to be Alison, but he suspects they know who'll die. Ali gets through to Jamal by telling him she still loves him. He asks for another chance, but she gently turns him down. The guy Jamal conned, JD, beats him up as Casey watches. Kevin tells Paige he's convinced she's an angel. Amy remembers her promise to her father- Harris- to avenge his death, then vows Ian will die and fill the 5th chair.